It seems like a lot of Christians have been weighing in on one particular political issue this election season: Prop 8, the marriage clause. There was some pretty amazing organization on the part of faith-based orgs. to get petitions signed to get this on the ballot. It seems like the main argument for keeping marriage between a man and a woman is: because the Bible says so/that’s what God intended. I have also been told that Christians should vote yes on this prop (to make the law say marriage is between man and woman) because the Bible is the authority. There has also been quite a bit of frenzy around schools in Massachusets supposedly teaching about gay marriage/homosexuality in schools. I have a couple thoughts on this prop and these arguments, which if you care to read, you will find below.
1) The first thing that strikes me about the Christian response to this prop is the call for unity and action on this issue, and the general assumption that if you’re a Christian, you will automatically vote yes (unless you’re a Methodist, that is). Why is this the issue that Christians mobilize around and get really vocal on? Why aren’t we collectively angry that there is still an unjust war going on in which innocent people are getting killed everyday, while our future unborn children are getting saddled with debt? Why aren’t we collectively angry that our nation seems completely unconcerned that our education system is in shambles, that our children grow up learning how to take tests instead of think critically and write well. Why is it always the gay issue that the church rallies around as the moral threat to our nation?
2) Marriage is not now what God once intended it to be. This is evident in the fact that Christians have the same divorce rate as secular society, by domestic violence rates both in Christian and non-Christian households, by the whole notion of pre-nuptial agreements. Anyone can get married; there is no pre-license interview in which you must pledge to fight for your marriage, avoiding divorce at all costs; there is no agreement you must sign that says “I will not cheat on my spouse or beat them or emotionally abuse them or withhold sex;” you can be of any religion, and you don’t even have to believe in God. Christians are so hypocritical on this issue when it comes to divorce. Many churches have divorce support groups; there is just no question that we’re perfectly fine with divorce. It’s not what God wanted, but it happens is the church’s attitude. I have never heard of divorce or remarried people being turned away from a church or denied leadership positions, but it happens all the time for gay people. You want to gay people to have rights, just not be able to get married; you want to call it “civil unions?” Fine, but then all “unions” should be called such, because clearly not all marriages are what God intended.
3) In this country, we have separation of church and state. The Bible is no the constitution, the constitution is the constitution. Do we really want to live in a theocracy? The Arab world lives in theocracies, is that what we want in this country? But the Bible doesn’t call for jihads and oppression of women, you say. Some people think it does, and some people who thought it did did some very bad things because of it. There are all manner of interpretations of ANY spiritual document, and ours is no exception. We have separation of church and state for a very good reason, so that no one may impose and/or oppress others with their religious beliefs. Many awful things have been justified through a belief in the Christian faith; our Constitution at one time said that black people were only part human, and slavery was upheld and justified by citing scripture. The Bible’s words have been twisted to suit all manner of oppression, when truthfully, the bottom line was always monetary. Sometimes the courts make law because something is wrong and society is unwilling to change it. Example: many civil rights laws. Many, many people did not think segregation was wrong, and many many people today would like segregation to return. Do we put this to a popular vote? No, because it is wrong. We cannot oppress people because some people think it’s o.k. The court ruled on this issue and granted gay people the right to get married. Many gay people did. Now we’re proposing to legally say “PSYCH!,” just kidding! You don’t give someone something and then take it away. Especially civil rights.
4) Exactly what is it about gay relationships that so incenses Christians? If we say we’re not homophobic (and many Christians do say this), then why do we want to keep gay people from getting married? I know several gay/lesbian people in long-term relationships (longer than most straight couples I’ve known). I should look them in the eye and say “my relationship is better/more meaningful/more committed/more valid than yours because I’m straight?” Can anyone honestly do that? I know Christians that make exceptions in their general beliefs on this matter because of personal relationships; gay family members, co-workers, friends. Why do we do that? Why do we say, oh, well, you’re o.k. because I know you, but it’s not o.k. for everyone else. Wrong. It is in general, not o.k. to hate on anyone just because we don’t agree with what they’re doing. As for gay marriage being taught in school and children are going to be corrupted/consider being gay because they heard it in school. This is the most ludicrous bunch of malarchy I’ve ever heard. If you don’t want your kids to know that gay people exist, you’re setting them up to be a really ignorant member of society. Just because they hear it at school doesn’t mean they will do it/be it. This is where parents come in, teaching their kids about right and wrong, etc. We teach our kids a lot of things at school that are scary, wrong, and shameful; many of them having to do with some things our country has done. Hopefully our kids will not be racist because they learn that our country enslaved people for a very long time, threw Japanese people in internment camps for no good reason, and is currently suspending the civil rights of ANYONE you and I might consider a terrorist/unpartiotic (the Patriot Act, anyone?).
My thoughts are not to condemn anyone who is in favor of Prop 8, only to explain why I am against it, and why I think people should think a bit more critically before deciding. I voted NO on prop 8 (Iabsentee ballot), and believe Jesus is good with that. I don’t think I recall any time when he said it was cool to actively oppress other/deny others rights based on our belief in him. I am prepared to have people tell me I’m not really a Christian, that I’m going against God/the Bible, and all that kind of thing, but I don’t care. I will listen and have listened to all the arguments in favor, and I don’t spit in people’s faces just because I don’t agree with them. I know this is a tough issue, and it is especially tough use your voting power (because it IS power) when you think you might be going against God. I don’t think people who vote in favor of Prop 8 are bad people, just as I hope they wouldn’t think that of me.














